Sigalon - The Swedish Frog

"We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars". Oscar Wilde
« Back to blog
September 02, 2008

"Just How Stupid Are We? Facing the Truth About the American People" - By Rick Shenkman

Interviews & Features

History News Network

Journalism is said to be the first draft of history. But journalists traditionally have had little use for historians. The list of occasions on which journalists feel compelled to call upon historians is short. Though a select number of historians recently have become media stars, the fact remains that few are publicly quoted, and hardly any are given the public platform regularly awarded economists, political scientists or pollsters. The last historian trusted to take a large and visible role in a national administration was Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., and that was forty years ago.

Given how public opinion is shaped today, whipsawed emotionally on talk shows this way and that in response to the egos of the guests, the desire for ratings by the hosts and the search for profits by media companies and sponsors, historians are especially needed now. They can help remind us of the superficiality of what-happens-today-is-all-that-counts journalism.

Among the many duties we assume are these: To expose politicians who misrepresent history. To point out bogus analogies. To deflate beguiling myths. To remind Americans of the irony of history. To put events in context. To remind us all of the complexity of history.

 



Comments (3)
Sep 02, 2008

Imperfect said...
I don't disagree with anything in the clip - other than the title? Why is the title specific to Americans when the article barely even mentions them? It seems to me that this could be said of everyone, no?

Sep 02, 2008

Sigalon said...
In his book, Rick Shenkman eliminates any remaining doubt about the growing inadequacy of the American electorate to participate responsibly in democracy. A few of the chilling facts with which the book is crammed:

--half of us can name 4 characters from "The Simpsons," but less than a quarter can name more than one of the guaranteed rights in the First Amendment.

--only 2 out of 5 voters can name all three branches of the federal government.

--only 1 in 5 know that there are 100 federal senators.

--only 1 in 7 can find Iraq on a map.

--only one-fifth of Americans between ages 18-34 bother to keep up with current events.

Does the ignorance of the voters in the self proclaimed Greatest Democracy on Earth apply to other nations - probably and sadly so.

Sep 02, 2008

Imperfect said...

Thanks for the reply. The post didn’t seem to have but one word that related to America, so the point was lost on me.  I fear – like you – that ignorance is a plague that ravages not one nation, but the world.

 

As an American, I have grave concern about the issues you raise. I don’t dismiss the points you raise, but I would also posit that because of the Internet, things are changing quite dramatically.  Younger people have better access to information thanks to the Internet than do older generations. I think that this is ultimately going to be a game changer. Believe it or not, YouTube has done more than MTV ever did.  It will continue on.  I sure hope it will. Blog on!

 

Those of us that live in large costal cities (NY, Boston, Washington, LA, San Francisco, and Seattle) do much to power the thought and economic leadership of the nation. The vast middle of the nation (other than perhaps Chicago) is as fortunate – yet they have “leadership” on family “values”  I think what you see happening in US politics a battle between “values” and economics.   The coasts vote Democratic and the middle votes Republican.  It’s ironic indeed given that the middle class are voting for upper class tax cuts and the rich are voting for higher taxes!  Strange indeed.  In the end, the reason why I think you (and hopefully the world) will be pleasantly surprised by the US is that despite the enormous mistakes our leadership can make – the public can correct for it every 4 years.  I think you can blame our leaders for much right now, but I’m hoping the American people will have the intelligence and will to correct for it.  I think we’re both in violent agreement!

 

 

Leave a comment...
 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login.
Click here to login or sign up